- Cleveland Real Estate Investors
- Posts
- π AmTrust stays downtown β but not the way you'd expect
π AmTrust stays downtown β but not the way you'd expect
π 40 new for-sale homes, no down payment trap


Good morning, Cleveland Real Estate Investors!
Donβt keep us a secret: Share the email with friends (copy URL here)β
π¬ In todayβs edition:
π The office math that explains Cleveland's market
π° Brownfields, big bets, and a 252% duplex
π East 55th is heating up β here's the proof
π° Cleveland Market Minute
Cleveland housing developments get funded, neighborhoods lifted
Three Cleveland developments won competitive, highly coveted tax credits that will help push each of those new housing projects toward construction. In total, the trio will add 165 affordable residential units. But one of them is actually the construction of 40 new houses that offer an opportunity at home ownership.
The three projects that won 9 percent Low Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC) from the Ohio Housing Finance Agency (OHFA).
π Read More
Downtown Cleveland: experience drives perception
Downtown Cleveland, Inc. (DCI) says that the biggest thing wrong with the cityβs central business district is that not enough people are familiar with it. If more people visited it more often, DCI said people would enjoy it more. And DCI has a survey of perceptions to back up its argument.
βExperience drives perceptionβ is one of the most prominent takeaways DCI gained about the city center. The data from DCIβs survey suggests that as people spend more time downtown, their views of safety and vibrancy improve significantly.
π Read More
Edgewater, West Blvd grapple with new development
Clevelandβs Edgewater, Cudell, and West Boulevard neighborhoods are currently facing a small wave of development, ranging from renovations to new construction. But the path to groundbreaking has been easier for some projects than others.
At the southwest corner of West and Clifton Boulevards, six townhomes proposed by local builder SmartBuilt Development LLC and designed by Sixmo Architecture of Cleveland faced significant opposition from neighbors at a City Planning Commission meeting on May 1.
π Read More
IN PARTNERSHIP WITH MEMORYGRAM
BBB Accredited Β· USA Based Β· The Only Memoir Service That Calls Them Β· Father's Day Sale
Your Dad, Your Grandparent, Your Parent β Has a Lifetime of Stories You've Never Heard. Memorygram Captures Them in a Beautiful Hardcover Book Before They're Gone Forever.
There are stories your parents and grandparents haven't told anyone. How they met. What they were afraid of at 25. The moment they realized they'd become who they were meant to be. The risks they took. The things they wish they'd done differently.
Memorygram sends them one thoughtful question per week by email β or calls them on the phone and interviews them directly. They just speak or write their answer, add a photo, and Memorygram does the rest. When they're done, it all becomes a premium 8.5" Γ 11" hardcover book β their story, in their own words, with QR codes that play their voice for future generations.
π Father's Day Sale: 20% Off Β· No Shipping Β· Schedule Delivery for June 15
π Just Sold Spotlight β Historic High-Rise Condo with Brand-New Windows, Skyline Views & Walkable Downtown Living at The Pointe at Gateway
π 1326 W 110th St, Cleveland, OH 44102
π° Sold Price: $360,000
π Size: 2,700 sq. ft.
π Year Built: 1920
π 6 Beds | π 3 Full Baths
π Driveway
π³ Lot Size: 5,558 sq. ft.
π« School District: Cleveland Municipal School District
π Investor Takeaway
At $133/sq. ft. on a fully gut-renovated duplex with three-unit income potential, this W. 110th Street multifamily closed right at its $360,100 Zestimate β a rare alignment of market value and sale price that signals strong pricing discipline. With projected rental income of ~$4,000/month across all three units, the gross yield picture is compelling for Cleveland's near west side, where demand from both renters and owner-occupants continues to tighten inventory. A 2023 roof, dual new HVAC units, new hot water tanks, and new windows mean near-zero deferred maintenance β a meaningful distinction for investors underwriting long-term hold strategies. The property has appreciated 252% over the last decade, making it one of the stronger appreciation stories in the 44102 zip code.
π‘ Neighborhood Insight
π Community: Near West Side, Cleveland
π Nearby Landmarks: Edgewater Beach, Downtown Cleveland, local parks, shopping and entertainment corridors
πΆ Accessibility: Walkable to parks and retail; 5 minutes to Edgewater and downtown
πΏ Lifestyle Appeal: A rapidly appreciating near west corridor balancing urban access with residential density β ideal for the live-in landlord or seasoned multifamily investor
π Recent Sales Nearby:
1289 W 115th St β $353,000 | 5 Bed | 3 Bath
10105 Baltic Rd β $336,000 | 5 Bed | 3 Bath | 2.6k sq. ft.
2049 West Blvd β $418,000 | 5 Bed | 3 Bath | 2.5k sq. ft.
2095 Lark St, Lakewood β $310,000 | 7 Bed | 4 Bath | 2.6k sq. ft.
3123 West Blvd β $240,000 | 6 Bed | 2 Bath | 2.8k sq. ft.
π Notable Features
π Three-unit multifamily layout β first floor, second floor, and third-floor suite with kitchenette
π½ Gourmet kitchens across units with quartz countertops, high-quality cabinetry, and stainless appliances
π Spacious open-concept living rooms on both main units with seamless kitchen flow
π½ Second floor includes formal dining room and 3-bedroom configuration with full modern bath
π Third floor features a large bonus room with kitchenette and full bath β flex income or owner suite
πΏ Front porch and balcony for outdoor living
π§ Major 2023β2025 updates: new roof (2023), 2 new AC units, new hot water tanks, new windows, new flooring, new fixtures, fresh paint throughout
π° Projected rental income of ~$4,000/month β live-in landlord or full cash flow play
β Seller warranty included; eligible for Cash, Conventional, FHA, and VA financing
π‘ Insiderβs Insight
π’ AmTrust Bets $14M on Staying Downtown

π The Move
AmTrust is splitting its Greater Cleveland office presence, relocating part of its workforce to suburban Mayfield Heights while keeping roughly a third downtown at the AECOM Building, 1300 E. 9th St.

π° The Investment
$14M tenant buildout for 51,397 sq ft across the 2nd and 3rd floors
$200K already spent on interior demolition to clear the space
Architectural, electrical, mechanical, and plumbing modifications planned
βοΈ The Irony Worth Noting
AmTrust's $14M renovation is more than 3x what its current tower (800 Superior) just sold for
It also exceeds the $11M owner Rugby Realty put into renovating the entire 21-story building after buying it in 2018
π The Building It's Leaving
800 Superior (587,118 sq ft, 23 stories) sold May 1 for just $4M to a Kassouf family affiliate
AmTrust leased ~300,000 sq ft there for 15 years; lease expires at year's end
Second-largest tenant National General also exiting β leaving major vacancy
County appraised the tower at $19.6M last year, a $10M drop from 2022
π Investor Takeaway
A landmark downtown tower trading at $4M while a single tenant spends $14M to renovate suburban-adjacent space tells the story of a bifurcating office market: flight to quality and amenities, with older bulk-square-footage assets repricing hard. As Newmark's Terry Coyne put it, the winners and losers are already identifiable.
π’ What does AmTrust's $14M downtown bet tell you about Cleveland's office market? |
π Tax Credits Power 165 New Affordable Units Across Cleveland

π The Awards
Three Cleveland projects won competitive 9% Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC) from the Ohio Housing Finance Agency, part of $39.1M in statewide awards. The program can subsidize up to 70% of construction costs.

π₯ Lorain Avenue Redevelopment β $27.2M
62-unit general-occupancy apartment building in Ohio City
Replaces the aging, nearly vacant McCafferty Health Center
Ground-floor space becomes Ohio City Inc.'s permanent office
Serves households at 30β70% of Area Median Income (Cleveland median: ~$40,801)
Construction could begin mid-2027 β pending demolition funding
π₯ Living At 55 β $21M
Senior housing (55+) at 1401 E. 55th St. in St. Clair-Superior
Built on the former Frank Sterle's Slovenian Country House site (closed 2017, demolished 2023)
Cleveland Clinic backing the project with a $1M grant to co-developer Famicos
Construction targeted before end of 2027
π₯ South Collinwood SFLP Homes β $14.56M
40 new single-family lease-to-purchase homes on former land-bank lots
~36 three-bedroom two-story homes + 4 accessible one-story homes
Offered to families at or below 60% AMI
CHN's lease-purchase model: a 15-year, coached pathway to ownership (1,800+ homes transferred to date)
π The Bigger Picture
$2.5M loan + $10M in 4% LIHTC also went to Union at Cleveland Harbor
$64M Warner Swasey redevelopment breaks ground June 1
Retail following residential: A to Z Furniture expanding ($590K), new AutoZone ($1.6M) on E. 55th
π Investor Takeaway
The East 55th corridor and Ohio City are absorbing serious public capital, and one project here is for-sale housing, not just rentals β South Collinwood's lease-to-purchase model builds owner-occupants and long-term neighborhood stability. As Famicos director John Anoliefo noted, out-of-state partners are circling E. 55th. Subsidized construction lifts surrounding comps and signals where private capital tends to follow.
π‘House of the Week β Remodeled Corner Townhome in One of Ohio City's Most Coveted Private Courts
π π 3901 Vine Ct, Cleveland, OH 44113
π° Price: $375,000
π Size: 1,410 sq ft
π Year Built: 2009
π 3 Beds | π 1 Full Bath + 1 Half Bath
π Attached 1-Car Garage
π‘ Corner Townhouse | Clinton Court, Ohio City
π« School District: Cleveland Metropolitan School District
π§ Vibes: Tucked behind garden-lined walkways off Clinton Avenue β one of Ohio City's most sought-after addresses β this light-filled corner townhome is the rare find that checks every box without asking you to compromise. Fully updated, move-in ready, and priced for a buyer who recognizes that location and lifestyle at $266 per square foot in this zip code is genuinely hard to replicate.
The floor plan is efficient but lives large. A first-floor flex suite β easily deployed as a home office, guest room, or private gym β establishes the versatility early. The main living level delivers on natural light through large picture windows, with a renovated kitchen as the clear centerpiece: white quartz countertops, custom tile backsplash, curated lighting, a coffee bar area, and a full stainless steel appliance suite β a remodel done with intention, not just a surface refresh. The living area flows directly onto a private rear deck, freshly repaired and re-stained this year, extending the usable footprint for morning routines and evening entertaining alike. A powder room completes the main level.
π Listed by: Allie Carr | Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Professional Realty
π 216-952-8884 | βοΈ [email protected]
π Tools & Resources We Recommend
PropStream β Lead generation + property comps
AirDNA β Short-term rental profitability data
BiggerPockets Cap Rate Guide β Know how to calculate investment ROI
Cleveland Housing Court Tracker β Spot eviction risks and distressed deals
Cleveland Real Estate Investor Facebook Group β Share deals and insights with local investors
π£ Weekly Wrap-Up
π° Cleveland Real Estate Weekly | Downtown Repositioning, Affordable Housing & Near West Side Momentum
Clevelandβs real estate market continues evolving through a mix of downtown reinvestment, public-backed housing expansion, and rising demand across key west-side neighborhoods. While older office assets struggle nationally, Cleveland is seeing renewed confidence in upgraded urban product and long-term neighborhood development.
π Market Momentum: Office Repricing, Public Capital & Housing Expansion
This week highlighted the growing divide within commercial real estate. AmTrustβs $14M investment into Downtown Cleveland offices β while its former tower sold for just $4M reinforces a clear βflight to qualityβ trend reshaping the office sector.
π‘ Takeaway: Cleveland remains a value-driven market where public investment, infrastructure, and neighborhood positioning continue attracting long-term capital despite broader national uncertainty.
π Just Sold Spotlight | Renovated Near West Side Multifamily
π 1326 W 110th St, Cleveland, OH 44102
π° $360,000 | π 2,700 sq ft
This fully gut-renovated three-unit multifamily closed directly at Zestimate value, signaling disciplined pricing and strong investor demand on Clevelandβs near west side.
π‘ Insider Insight
Clevelandβs market is becoming increasingly segmented β and more strategic.
Older office buildings without modernization are repricing aggressively, while upgraded, amenity-driven assets continue attracting investment. At the neighborhood level, areas receiving sustained public funding and housing incentives are beginning to establish long-term redevelopment momentum that private capital is following closely.
The bigger trend is clear: Clevelandβs growth story is no longer just about affordability β itβs increasingly about targeted reinvestment, infrastructure-backed stability, and neighborhood identity.
π‘ House of the Week | Remodeled Ohio City Corner Townhome
π 3901 Vine Ct, Cleveland, OH 44113
π° $375,000 | π 1,410 sq ft
A fully updated corner-unit townhome tucked inside Ohio Cityβs sought-after Clinton Court community, featuring renovated interiors, quartz countertops, private outdoor living space, and walkability to one of Clevelandβs strongest lifestyle corridors.
Cleveland Real Estate Investors
π© Donβt keep us a secret: Share the email with friends Forward the newsletter.




Reply